When rights are transformed and owners pick units, several owners often want the same one. Staff handling a conflict need to know where it sits, what options exist, and how to talk with the owners involved. Urbird|Urban renewal, from plan to handover puts these in one place. The war room lists every conflict. The coordination suggestion works out in advance the arrangement that sends the fewest owners to a lottery. The selection reference, generated the moment staff open it, is a short letter to the owner showing what switching and staying each look like. The owner decides. The document runs two A4 pages with a phone version. Desktop downloads a PDF, phones share an image, and a LINE message can carry it.
One rule in the regulations
Article 17 of the Implementing Rules for Rights Transformation says positions are assigned under the selection principles in the plan. When two or more owners apply for the same position, a public lottery decides, and the application window must be at least 30 days. The text gives no priority to the earliest applicant, so registration time is no reason to rank anyone. The system records when each choice was entered but does not sort by it, and rights value is ignored as well. Under Articles 3 and 5, the plan states how applications and lotteries run, and the implementer surveys owners' preferences for positions first.
War room: see which conflict to handle first
During selection, staff work from a to-do board called the war room. The screen has tabs for conflicts, over-selection, members and recent actions. On the right sits the same 3D building the owners use, recolored for selection status. Click a conflict card and the 3D lights up only that case, and a destination button flies the camera there. The view refreshes on a timer, and the tab and expanded card are kept in the address, so pasting it to a colleague opens the same spot.
- Conflict cards: one card is one contested position, the header shows how many owners, and each owner takes one line. Money and the second and third choices appear only when a line is opened. Order decides which case to handle first. Registration time and rights value play no part.
- Table color blocks: one row per owner with rights value, selectable range and choices 1 through 3, each unit shown as a block. Red is a first-choice conflict, orange is a second or third choice that someone else ranked first, green is the only owner ranking it first, and gray is only a backup. Short text on every block keeps it readable in black-and-white print.
- Over-selection tab: units whose selected amount exceeds the rights value are gathered in one tab for staff to confirm.
Coordination suggestion: no lottery when none is needed
Whenever a conflict appears, the system has a coordination suggestion ready, so staff do not start from nothing. The suggestion is computed by a fixed algorithm, so the same data gives the same result every time. Three principles apply. When there are enough places, each contested position keeps one owner, the rest move to different units, and nobody needs a lottery. When there are not enough, the number of owners sent to a lottery is the smallest possible. Registration order and rights value are not considered, and a tie is shown as a tie for coordination or a public lottery.
- A conflict appearsTwo or more owners list the same unit as first choice
- The system computes a suggestionEvery candidate unit passes the same rules as the owner side
- Enough placesNo lotteryEach contested position keeps one owner and the rest move to different units
- Not enough placesFewest owners in a lotteryEveryone else lands on a unit from the owner's own list
- Arrangements tieMark the tieLeft to coordination or a public lottery
An illustration of results and principles.
A suggestion is only a suggestion, and there is no apply button. Staff and owners talk first and decide who stays and who switches, and positions that cannot be settled go to a public lottery under Article 17. Any alternative unit must pass the same rules the owner side uses, including selectable range, unit shape, whether the unit is open and whether it has a price, so an owner can actually pick any unit the suggestion names.
Selection reference: a short letter to the owner
When a conflict arises, staff open an owner's selection reference in the war room and the document is produced on the spot, for any pair of units. It reads like a short letter from the implementer to the owner. Two opening sentences say why this one was sent. Next is a three-box summary of layout, position and money. Below the boxes are 3D views and floor plans of both units, and one line of verdict that says the two are alike, the alternative is better, or the current choice is better. The data time sits at the top right, and everything reflects registrations and prices at the moment of opening.
At the bottom, switching and staying sit side by side at the same size, and the owner decides. The switching side explains how: change a choice to this unit on the platform, or ask staff to handle it, and it notes that this unit also follows the selection principles, depends on everyone's registrations at the deadline, and is not held for anyone. The staying side says nothing more needs doing. The document never pushes. It ends with one sentence: this is a reference, and registrations are not changed by it.
The second page is a fixed comparison table, the same items for every owner, easy to compare side by side.
| Item | Current choice | If switching |
|---|---|---|
| Winter solstice sunlight | About 4 hours | About 5 hours |
| Summer west sun | Stronger | Weaker |
| Window view | Average | More open |
| Greenery outside | A few treetops | A full row of street trees |
| Cross ventilation | One-sided light | Air through both sides |
The table is an illustration, and the real items are calculated from public weather and building data. For money, the document shows the appraised price of both units and the difference, with the balance payment in two columns, now and if switching. With illustrative figures, the payment now is NT$1.2 million, the payment if switching is NT$1.56 million, and the difference is NT$360,000, so subtracting the two columns reconciles. When a parking space changes, one more sentence states the difference, and a joint selection shows the group total. The balance is estimated on the spot, and the official amount follows the approved rights transformation plan.
An illustrative flow.
The staying side also states what a lottery would mean. If coordination fails, a public lottery follows the selection principles. After the deadline only the first choice counts. An owner who loses can only pick again from the units everyone else left over. The document is plain, so the owner knows what each side involves before any lottery.
Staff briefing: what may be said aloud stays off the document
Staff also have a briefing panel that sits outside the document. PDFs and images cannot include it. It is collapsed by default, down to one line, and written for staff only.
| Field | Content |
|---|---|
| For whom | Owner name, whether the alternative is which of the owner's choices or another unit, and the data time |
| May say aloud | How many owners currently list this unit as first choice; if coordination fails, a public lottery follows the rules |
| Do not say | How many owners currently rank the other unit first, and how many hold it as a backup |
| Reminders | PDF and image sending are disabled until prices load; when the gap is large, talk in person or by phone first |
When the gap between the two units is large, the panel warns that sending the letter directly may make the owner feel demoted, and suggests a conversation first or a look at the other units open to discussion. That list gives a summary per unit: how many items favor the alternative, how many favor the current choice, and how the balance changes from now to switching. One click switches to another unit. When another owner is also being suggested the same unit, the system asks staff to stagger the moves.
Lottery records and settlement
Positions still contested after the suggestion go to a public lottery under Article 17, and staff record the result before locking. Settlement at the deadline works by group. If any member of a group is in conflict, the whole group stays open, and an owner who loses can pick the whole group again. Settlement only calculates and writes nothing, and the list can serve as a draft of the lottery notice. After the plan is approved and announced, an owner who objects files in writing within two months under Article 53 of the Urban Renewal Act.
What to confirm before rollout
Selection principles are set project by project, so the application window, lottery procedure and plan contents are confirmed for each project. To talk it through, contact the development team.
POLISH builds with the war room, coordination suggestion and selection reference. The full feature set is on the urban renewal system page, and the urban renewal system case shows how it runs.
